Forbidden Chalice
Spell Quick

Forbidden Chalice

  • Archetype:
  • Forbidden

  • View:
  • 9636




Target 1 face-up monster on the field; until the end of this turn, that target gains 400 ATK, but its effects are negated.




 
 
AI Power Analysis
Negation/InteractionConfidence: MediumEvaluated Oct 9, 2026
59± 6/ 100
Power Score
Intrinsic 58
Deck 59

Forbidden Chalice — Power Evaluation

Final Score: 59 ± 6 · Confidence: Medium

  • Intrinsic: 58 · Deck: 59 · Meta: provisional
  • Primary role: Negation/Interaction · Secondary: Utility

Why it scores here

Forbidden Chalice is a Quick-Play that negates one face-up monster's effects for the turn, so its value comes from that soft interaction, not from its +400 ATK clause, which earns nothing on its own. It is run in 400 of 400 sampled decks at about 2.4 copies each and sits in top-partner lists with staples such as Ash Blossom and Droll, so it is reliably accessible and cheap to run. The 80.6 average power index is inflated by the boards it appears in: it is never a starter, searched, or material piece in the 8 recorded boards, so the score does not credit those boards.

Axis scores

Axis Score Evidence
Accessibility 70 Quick-Play in 400 decks at 2.4 copies on average, but not a searched or starting card in any recorded board (observed).
Combo & Conversion 35 Appears in 8 of 8 recorded boards with high power indexes, but combo role is empty and it is never a starter or payoff, so it converts nothing itself (observed).
Resource Economy 45 Costs itself to negate one monster effect for a turn, a roughly even one-for-one with no card advantage or refuel (verified text, inferred).
Effect & Interaction 50 Targets a face-up monster and negates its effects until end of turn, which is soft, situational interaction with no permanent answer (verified text).
Material Utility 0 A Spell Card cannot be used as material, so this axis scores at the floor (verified card type).
Resilience & Flexibility 45 Usable in response on the opponent's turn and across many archetypes, but a single negate or a face-down monster can blank it (inferred).
Deck-Building Efficiency 80 Generic Quick-Play with no garnet or lock clause, 2 to 3 copies are cheap to run, and it is splashable (observed deck copy distribution, verified text).

Calculation

Weight profile: Primary role Negation/Interaction, no secondary blend. Intrinsic ≈ 58, Deck ≈ 59, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: none. Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck

Strengths

  • Quick-Play response that works on an opponent's face-up monster in any turn it is held
  • Generic, archetype-agnostic card seen in 140 distinct archetypes
  • Cheap to run at 2 to 3 copies with no garnet or lock restriction

Weaknesses

  • Negates effects only until the end of the turn, so it is not a permanent answer
  • Only hits face-up monsters, so face-down or unsummoned threats are out of reach
  • The +400 ATK clause can help the monster it targets, which matters when the target is the opponent's

Counters / choke points

  • Hand traps that negate or respond to the Chalice itself, such as Ash Blossom & Joyous Spring (inferred)
  • Monster effects that are not negated by a Spell, or boards that do not depend on the targeted monster's effect (inferred)

Best use

Negation/Interaction. Decks: Archfiend, Darklord, Resonator, Branded, Exosister.

Evidence & gaps

  • Verified: Card text: targets 1 face-up monster, +400 ATK, its effects negated until end of turn; Quick-Play Spell Card, no garnet or lock clause; 400 of 400 decks run it, mostly 3 copies (240 decks), average 2.44; 8 of 8 combo boards include it, 0 as starter, searched, material, or payoff
  • Observed: Top partners include Skull Meister, Mulcharmy Fuwalos and Ash Blossom & Joyous Spring; Average power index 80.6 across boards it appears in; Included in 140 distinct archetypes
  • Inferred: Primary role is Negation/Interaction based on the text; Ash Blossom & Joyous Spring is a plausible counter to the Chalice; Its +400 ATK clause is mostly irrelevant to score
  • Data gaps: No banlist token, assumed 3 copies (unlimited) Only 8 combo boards, too small to measure its own conversion rate No rulings or FAQ evidence for interactions with targeting or negation Guide snippets do not mention Forbidden Chalice directly











https://metaduelist.com/
Top